Showing posts with label media bias. Show all posts
Showing posts with label media bias. Show all posts

Sunday, 3 July 2011

Plagiarism and media denial

So the Johann Hari saga lumbers on. Hari published his apology in the Independent and on his website on Wednesday, in which he denied plagiarism, but admitted that 'in some instances' he used practices that were wrong and which he wouldn't repeat:
Why? Because an interview is not just an essayistic representation of what a person thinks; it is a report on an encounter between the interviewer and the interviewee. If (for example) a person doesn't speak very good English, or is simply unclear, it may be better to quote their slightly broken or garbled English than to quote their more precise written work, and let that speak for itself. It depends on whether you prefer the intellectual accuracy of describing their ideas in their most considered words, or the reportorial accuracy of describing their ideas in the words they used on that particular afternoon. Since my interviews are long intellectual profiles, not ones where I'm trying to ferret out a scoop or exclusive, I have, in the past, prioritised the former. That was, on reflection, a mistake, because it wasn't clear to the reader.
Personally, I found the apology to be a bit more of a justification than anything, but as Hari's rejection of plagiarism and churnalism was in tune with what I wrote on Tuesday, and as he apologised and admitted he was wrong, I was willing to let that be the end of it, at least until Hari publishes his next piece, which will presumably be thoroughly vetted first by his editors (which no longer include Simon Kelner), and then by his critics.

But by this time, some of those critics had had time to go back through more of Hari's work, and what emerged was not a picture of occasionally or 'in some instances' finding a more accurate quote for a badly expressed thought. Blogger Cheradenine Zakalwe got the ball rolling by comparing Hari's 2009 interview with Malalai Joya with her memoir Raising My Voice. Zakalwe's work was picked up by author Jeremy Duns, who pointed out that in addition to the 42 quotes lifted in whole or in part from Joya's book, there were also passages which appeared not as quotes from her but as Hari's own writing. The New Statesman's Guy Walters reported Dunn's findings and mentions similar problems with Hari's 2004 interview with Ann Leslie. Blogger Guido Fawkes posted that Hari was sacked from both Cambridge University's student newspaper in 1999 and as a writer for GQ for embellishing stories. The Council for the Orwell Prize announced that it was investigating the situation further.

A lot of the controversy has centred around whether what Hari did should actually be called plagiarism. On Tuesday, I wrote that it shouldn't. On Friday, I changed my mind. Not only is some of what Hari did actually textbook plagiarism - as in, taking words that Malalai Joya wrote and passing them off not even as quotes from her, but as his own writing - I believe that the sheer extent of Hari's so-called 'cleaning up' of quotes goes beyond the courtesy he and his defenders try to pretend he was doing the reader and the interviewee. Where quotes were taken from earlier interviews, I feel Hari was plagiarising not the words of the interviewee but the work of the interviewer, who had to ask the right questions and take the time to record/transcribe/parse through their interview to include the quote in their story. Hari didn't only pretend that the quote was said to him - he also pretended that he put in all of the work that's involved in getting that quote from the interviewee's mouth to the page.

What I've found most bizarre about this whole thing is the defences that have emerged for Hari in mainstream media, all of which seem to deliberately treat Hari's practice as barely worse than just removing ums and ahs from a transcript. The Independent's C J Schuler posted a blog on Tuesday calling the accusations against Hari 'extraordinarily naive'; Schuler, for some reason, maintained that Hari was likely a victim of authors who trot out the same anecdotes and thoughts over and over on book tours, often in the same words. Schuler seemed to have missed Hari's own admission earlier that day, which showed this was clearly not the case.

The Guardian's Mark Lawson wrote a seemingly well-intentioned piece yesterday, which suggested that journalists should use the controversy as an opportunity to reassess their own methods. However, Lawson's article ignores the developments in the story, falls back on Schuler's bit about media-savvy authors repeating themselves, and basically dismisses what Hari did as 'being too kind' to interviewees by giving them the opportunity to be quoted at their best. 'A small sin,' he says, 'in comparison to the numerous media interviews that choose to cruelly distort what was actually said in the interest of news value, malice or political purchase.' Ah yes, the old, 'sure this was wrong but what about this other thing which is also wrong and possibly more wrong!' Many of Hari's defenders pointed out journalistic shortcomings at the Daily Mail or the Sun in his defence; luckily for critics, a logical response to this kind of reasoning was at hand, and from Hari himself, no less.

Frankly baffling was former Guardian editor Peter Preston's piece in today's Observer, which says it's 'ethically ludicrous' for anonymous bloggers to be able to whip up a controversy over Hari's 'occasional habit...of using a cleaned-up, pre-written version of his subject's answers rather than a ... you know ... more um! ... rambling live response.' I refuse to believe that someone with Preston's experience is actually so obtuse as to not realise by this point that a) what Hari's accused of is (once again!) more than removing ums and ahs, b) that his critics are not at all anonymous (he refers to leftist blog DSG, which started the controversy, but conveniently ignores, oh, everyone since), and c) that this charge of ethical ludicrousness makes absolutely no sense at all. Even if Hari's detractors were anonymous, how would that mean that they have no ethical grounds to find fault with Hari?

Strange though these defences are, they actually all have one common theme: the journalists writing them don't seem to believe that we, the readers, really understand. If only we knew what it was like to interview someone. If only we were real journalists and not 'anonymous' bloggers and tweeters. Schuler actually writes that 'anyone who has ever actually conducted interviews or attended discussion will surely smell a rat', while Lawson and Preston use their columns to pour scorn on these riff-raff who use Twitter and blogs to expose wrongdoings.

Despite the fact that comments on earlier articles and debates on Twitter clearly showed that many, many people believed that there was far more to what Hari did than cleaning up quotes, these defences continue to pretend as if that's all it was. Lawson and Preston's articles both make clear what others have merely hinted at: they think we're idiots. We rabble don't understand what an article would look like if we didn't allow quotes to be cleaned up. An exact transcript would be a nightmare! You don't want that! Both ignore the fact that no one has asked for exact transcripts, only an accurate portrayal of an interview that actually took place and not a synopsis of an author's thoughts from elsewhere.

But the Guardian writers insist on telling us what we're angry about, and then telling us that we're wrong to be angry, rather than admitting that there's more to it. To me, this implies that the journalists believe that only they can really set the news agenda. Aside from Hari's actual writings, this story has come entirely from blogs and Twitter. And honestly, there seem to be a lot of mainstream journalists who have a problem with that. I don't believe that the news agenda should be set by 'Twit mobs', as they've been dubbed, which I think I set out pretty clearly on my earlier blog on the Ken Clarke fiasco. But when non-journalists discover a story, and that story is supported by real facts, denial by mainstream press just looks like fear at best and snobbery at worst.

Wednesday, 13 April 2011

On the Ottawa Sun

I confess, I haven't been paying as much attention to the election coverage as I'd hoped. And living in the UK means I missed last night's Canadian leadership debate, though I caught up on the highlights this morning. And then this article from the Ottawa Sun was brought to my attention. And this editorial.

This is election coverage at its worst. There is no mention of the policies discussed in the debate, just a transparent attempt to draw a link in readers' minds between Michael Ignatieff and Mao Zedong based on...what, exactly? Ignatieff did not quote Mao, but used a similar phrase. Whether he realised what he was doing or not, the Sun would have us believe that this comment is a real insight into Ignatieff's character, that lurking beneath the surface is a communist dictator waiting to seize power and kill millions of people. It's a pathetic bit of partisanship that has no place in journalism.

I wandered over to the Sun's website to check out the rest of their debate coverage. Their main story on their 'Debate' tab is 'Harper ahead in duel: Poll'. The headlines of the related stories: Iggy channels Mao, Cdns. heard message, Tories head for a majority, Harper best for battlefield, CBC compass points red, AG to investigate leaks, Tories fighting for faiths. Obvious bias?

Of course everyone knows that media outlets tend to have a political bias and often come right out and endorse one party. And Sun Media has never been shy about its Conservative leanings. But such heavily editorialised journalism, and editorials presented as news (as in the first Ignatieff article I posted above) are far over and above the kind of bias that can be detected in other media outlets; for example, the Toronto Star is often called out on its Liberal bias, but its debate coverage does not read like a list of Liberal Party talking points.

Some would say that the Sun papers are tabloids and we shouldn't expect the same standard of journalism there as in other publications. But the Ottawa Sun is a very popular daily paper, and while some people are aware of its bias or its shortcomings, many are not and read it the same way they would any paper: as a genuine source of news. Especially in an election campaign, I think it's disgustingly irresponsible to trot out opinions disguised as fact.

And yes, of course there are many journalists and media outlets guilty of this, across Canada and elsewhere. I've picked the Sun because of the horrible examples on hand, but by no means mean to say that there aren't others out there with the same problem!

Wednesday, 6 April 2011

Worth Sharing

Warning: if you're interested in this sort of thing, you may soon become lost in the articles/blogs linked in Andrew Potter's blog, and the ones linked in those pieces, etc. Maybe look through when you have some time on your hands and no deadline looming.


If you follow me on Twitter or we're friends on Facebook, you'll know that I promoted the Vote Compass as a fun way to see where you stand in relation to political parties. I didn't think of it as "see how you should vote" - I thought of it as "see how little you probably agree with the party line from the party you think you're supposed to vote for". I've read conflicting claims on whether the Compass is actually biased toward a Liberal vote (that is, that no matter what you put you'll almost always be told you're closest to the Liberal Party), and haven't looked into it myself yet, so I can't really comment on that at the moment.

First of all, people shouldn't be using the Vote Compass to figure out who they should vote for. If they genuinely don't know who to pick, the Compass might point them in the direction of a party or parties that they might want to look into further. If nothing else, the issues addressed in the questions may make them realise they actually care about those things, and look into what each party says about them.

But the fact that people who know who they want to vote for are upset because the Compass tells them to vote for the wrong party was exactly my point - people can become too fixated on the party line on issues, and on making that party line their opinion. When presented with opinions to choose from without having the party's opinion on hand, people may be surprised to find out their opinion is different - and that's okay. You can still vote for a party without agreeing with what they have to say on every issue. In fact, I doubt there's a single person alive who agrees with the party line on every issue - political parties are by nature pluralistic, and can't possibly be tailored to individuals. When you vote, you vote for the candidate or party that best represents your view and that you think would do the best job for your riding (well, country - regardless of the political system, many/most people likely still vote based on who they want to be Prime Minister, not who they want to be their local MP).

I'm interested to see how this whole thing plays out though - a new, different story when election campaigns provide same old, same old.

Tuesday, 5 April 2011

Belated Response

I never did get around to posting after the TUC protest a couple of weeks ago, which means I won't bother saying much about it now since it's all a bit outdated. I did have a look at the coverage on Sunday, and it was pretty much what you'd expect. The more liberal papers tended to run higher numbers of attendees (ranging up to 400,000) and their headlines played down the trouble caused by the more radical elements. The more conservative papers generally went with lower attendance estimates (as low as 200,000) and featured photos and headlines about violence and police more prominently. Headlines aside, though, the things that went on outside of the march - the occupation of Fortnum and Masons, the paintballs thrown at police officers and allegedly tax-dodging businesses on Oxford Street, the vandalism of the Olympic clock in Trafalgar Square - were really the main focus of all coverage. Some better-meaning pieces opened with a paragraph that pointedly recognised the mass of peaceful protesters, but still went on to talk quite a bit more about the rest. But even if 400,000 people are marching peacefully, it's still news if anyone goes and smashes windows and throws paint on Oxford Street, so it's wrong to think that there should somehow be no media coverage just because the protest leaders would rather highlight the peaceful elements.

Yesterday someone posted this article on Twitter, defending the Black Bloc's tactics. While I generally don't agree with it, I do think it makes an important point about the distinction between violence and vandalism. Commentary during and after protests from politicians, police, opponents and peaceful protesters always condemns the 'violence' perpetrated by a few rogue elements. But is breaking shop windows or spraypainting buildings and monuments really violence? If this were an isolated incident on any night of the week, it would just be vandalism, and not noteworthy at all. Of course, there have been incidents of some people attacking police with protest signs, bottles, bricks, etc., and of course this is violence. I just think it's important that we use the right words in the right context.

*****************************
The election campaign in Canada is under way, and I'm already annoyed. First, by the jibes being traded on Twitter by Michael Ignatieff and Stephen Harper over the possibility of a one-on-one debate. "You said this but now you've taken it back", "My staff offered this and got no response", blah blah blah. People who are trying to be elected as Prime Minister of a country should not be engaging in petty who said what, schoolyard taunting online. It's pathetic. Second, the condescending campaign sloganing: met with REAL CANADIANS today, repeating RURAL CANADIANS over and over to show they aren't forgotten. It's so transparent and superficial. And I know, I know, it's politics. Sometimes I just hope for something a little better from the people who are supposed to be our nation's great leaders.

Finally, I'd forgotten the most annoying thing of all about election campaigns - my partisan Facebook friends. My newsfeed is basically a list of articles about why Harper or Ignatieff is terrible and will ruin this country (or already has). Worse than these, which are presumably meant to at least educate, are the status updates that don't really mean anything and serve just to shout loudly about who that person is voting for and why everyone else is stupid for not doing so. Urgh. I wish we could have some sort of moratorium on party hacks for the duration of the campaign.

Friday, 25 March 2011

Election Time!

Quick thing to think about before today's post: tomorrow is the TUC March for the Alternative. By all accounts, it's going to be massive, though the UK papers have already started with stories about how it's going to be hijacked by extremists, violence is expected, etc. Keep an eye on the coverage - watch how different it is from the now-daily coverage of protests in the Middle East, Gulf and North Africa, which I mentioned in an earlier post. I'll try to post on Sunday when I've seen a bit of the coverage and find some examples. Or, who knows, maybe the coverage will be fair to the thousands who are likely to turn out and march peacefully and not focus on a few who might manage some destruction? Nah.

Actually, what are your thoughts on this? Is it irresponsible and/or sensationalist journalism to focus only on the bad bits and not give as much airtime to the grievances of the majority? Or is the destruction/violence legitimately the news, the thing people are going to want to see on TV and read about the next day? Does it give a skewed view of the participants? Is there a bias in coverage that assumes the protesters don't really have a right to be angry? Would love to hear some comments on this, from any country.

****************************************
I meant to post yesterday and link to a BBC story about the impending Canadian election, but I forgot and now it's been corrected. Some of you may have seen it, anyway. The reporter somehow managed to mix up Lawrence Martin, the political analyst he interviewed, with Lawrence Cannon, the Foreign Affairs Minister, resulting in a few choice quotes about how Canadians don't like Stephen Harper's 'autocratic' style...attributed to his Foreign Minister. The article also contained a photo of Jack Layton captioned "NDP leader and acting Deputy Mayor of Toronto". Classic example of super lazy journalism - Layton's (since edited) Wikipedia profile did indeed say he was acting Deputy Mayor of Toronto, which is presumably where that came from.

****************************************
So it's election time! In addition to the Canadian election, which could be as early as May 2, we have the referendum on Alternative Vote in the UK (which I get to vote in), UK local elections, and devolved parliamentary elections in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, all on May 5. Throw in important Portuguese and Nigerian elections and an Icelandic referendum I need to keep an eye on for work, and all in all I'm pretty much going to be saturated with election coverage for the next month or two (when there aren't revolutions, wars and natural disasters to distract me. Oh, wait...).

I think election coverage always makes for interesting reading/viewing/listening. For one thing, politicians are at their very most clichéd - everything is a soundbyte, a campaign promise, a slogan. I find it infuriating, but it makes for some good observations. Election campaigns are one of the times when the various news outlets' editorial biases show most strongly (including, of course, outright endorsing a party or candidate). I'm hoping that watching the Canadian and UK campaigns at the same time will provide for interesting insights. And of course, there's always room for a slip-up here, a scandal there, a "bigoted woman" comment with the mic still on (or Nick Clegg's recent "If we keep agreeing there'll be nothing to debate" aside). One thing we probably can't depend on is proper analysis of policies (or the for/against arguments, in the case of the referendum) - it's always more interesting for people to read politicians making outrageous statements about how their opponent will ruin the country than to actually engage in informing the public. I'll keep an eye out for any coverage that actually does this particularly well, or particularly badly.

Sunday, 20 February 2011

Media and Protest

I went to a discussion at the Frontline Club last week on whether the mainstream media 'gets' protest and how coverage of protest movements has been affected by social media. The talk had been scheduled ages ago, in the wake of the student protests in the UK over tuition fees and the education maintenance allowance, but since then, Tunisia and Egypt happened, and Bahrain and Libya were on the brink. As a result, the panel included a BBC editor, an Al Jazeera English reporter, the founder of a media website and a student protest organiser. The debate and the questions afterward ended up focusing quite a bit on the role of blogs, Facebook and especially Twitter in organising protests and getting the word out about what's going on.

What I noticed, though, was this. When people talk about the movements in Tunisia and especially Egypt, it is with an air of total hope, pride and agreement. And the mainstream media coverage is in large part responsible for informing that view, for perpetuating it in the way these stories are covered. Aside from a few articles questioning the future of Israeli-Egypt relations should Mubarak's regime fall, there never seemed to be any question in anyone's mind (except Ezra Levant in a February 1 Ottawa Sun piece) as to whether the protests in Egypt were inherently good. Coverage was glowing. Any and all damage or problems were attributed to police, paid Mubarak thugs, unruly elements. Never were the protesters generally described as anything other than great. Which was fine for me, because that happens to gel with my personal view, and I was happy for the Egyptians and Tunisians for what they had done and the future they could now hope for.

But then I thought about what this discussion could have been about if it had happened a month earlier, or if Tunisia and Egypt hadn't happened yet. A discussion about the way the media dealt with the student protests in the UK would not have been this positive. Mainstream coverage of domestic protests almost always focuses on what goes wrong. The biggest stories to come out of the tuition fee protests were the damage at Millbank Tower, the kid who threw the fire extinguisher off the roof of said tower, the attack on Prince Charles and Camilla's car, and Pink Floyd guitarist David Gilmour's son Charlie's various charges for his involvement. There was no talk of revolution. There was no obvious slant to the reporting that said what the students were protesting for was right or wrong, no tone that made them obvious heroes. There were quotes from protest organisers and student leaders condemning the violence and saying it was caused by a small minority, but this didn't translate into the media coverage in the same way it later would for Egypt. Most people would look at the TV coverage or the newspapers the next day and say, "Look at those students destroying everything." There were citizen journalists, bloggers, Twitter users out there during the protests, posting their views on what was happening, reports and pictures of police brutality or peaceful activity. But there was no media embrace of these people, no big fuss about how Twitter was revolutionising the movement, no scramble to identify the most important bloggers/tweeters and make sure we always had their opinion.

And so, why the difference? Before the Q&A part of the Frontline Club event, and right before my phone died and I lost the ability to follow the livetweeting of it, I tweeted, "Different stories here - does msm romanticise protests elsewhere but vilify them at home?" Then, realising where I was, I decided to put the question to the panelists - between a protest leader, a BBC editor, the CEO of a citizen journalist website and an Al Jazeera reporter with experience in the British media, surely there would be some interesting ideas? People asked many questions about the role of social media, all met with long, thoughtful comments from the speakers. Finally, it was my turn, and I asked about the difference in the way international and domestic protest is covered. Does it have to do, I wondered, with political or corporate agendas, with a plurality of views available, with an inability to identify a definite enemy, with having more reporters on the ground and not needing the Twitter view?

And the answer was...nothing. The question was virtually ignored. The moderator, actually, said it was a great question and commented that as a former foreign correspondent, he could attest to the fact that in foreign reporting you are allowed to sort of "take a view" on things, to decide who are the good guys and the bad guys and report from that perspective. He then deferred to the BBC editor, who shook his head and said he had already spoken a lot tonight. The Al Jazeera reporter said that the question didn't really apply to her as Qatar-based AJ doesn't really have any news. And so, in a joke about the lack of anything happening in Doha, the question was lost and the panelists moved on to the next one. I was disappointed. I had really hoped for some answers on this.

When I got home, I saw a tweet from the BBC editor, responding to my last comment, saying "good point". When I asked him for his views again, he said they were "not for public consumption". The next day, I noticed a discussion between the website CEO and someone who had attended - and the CEO commented that he was more interested by my question than the point they were discussing. You know, the question he didn't say one word about at the debate.

In the end, I was left with two questions. One: what are the factors that contribute to such differences in the way protests are covered at home and abroad? I have some ideas, ranging from the fact that the public's a lot less forgiving about damages when it's their own stuff being destroyed, when it's their city up on the TV screen, to political influences in editorial decisions, to snobbery about the role of citizen journalists, to the need to simplify international problems into good guys and bad in a way we can't do here, to the fact that you just can't get everyone behind hating David Cameron and Nick Clegg in the way you can for Hosni Mubarak. And two: why don't journalists want to talk about it?